I Tested ChatGPT vs DeepSeek with 11 Creative Writing Prompts — Here’s the Surprising Winner

AI writing tools are getting better every day, but can they really be creative? I wanted to find out. So, I tested ChatGPT and DeepSeek with 11 creative writing prompts to see which one tells better stories, writes better poems, and comes up with more original ideas.

Both AIs did a good job in many ways. They followed instructions, used proper grammar, and wrote clear sentences. But when it came to creativity, emotions, and storytelling, one was clearly better than the other.

If you love writing or want to use AI to help with creative projects, this test will show you which tool is the best choice. The results surprised me, and they might surprise you too!

So, which AI was better? Which one made mistakes? And most importantly, which one should you use? Let’s find out.

1.The Variants of Vampires

Prompt:

Think of an alternative vampire that survives on something other than blood. Write a story or scene based on this character.

ChatGPT Reply:

Deepseek Reply:

Winner: DeepSeek

While ChatGPT’s response, “The Hunger of the Echofiend,” is atmospheric and aligns well with the prompt, DeepSeek’s “The Siphon of Starlight” offers a more emotionally resonant and character-driven narrative. DeepSeek’s story explores themes of loneliness, connection, and hope, weaving a unique concept of feeding on starlight with a heartfelt human connection. The poetic imagery and emotional depth make it more compelling and memorable.

ChatGPT’s response, though eerie and creative, leans heavily into horror tropes and lacks the same level of emotional engagement or character development. DeepSeek’s focus on storytelling and emotional payoff gives it the edge, making it the winner.

2.Spinning the Globe

Prompt:

Imagine that a character did the old spin the globe and see where to take your next vacation trick. Write a story or scene describing where they went and how their trip panned out.

ChatGPT Reply:

Deepseek Reply:

Winner: DeepSeek

While ChatGPT’s response, “Lost in the Spin,” is engaging and captures the spirit of adventure, DeepSeek’s “The Spin of Fate” offers a richer, more emotionally resonant narrative. DeepSeek’s story delves deeper into Elliot’s personal transformation, emphasizing themes of letting go, connection, and self-discovery. The vivid descriptions of Taveuni’s landscapes and the heartfelt interactions with the locals create a more immersive and memorable experience.

ChatGPT’s response is fun and lighthearted, with moments of humor and cultural immersion, but it lacks the same depth of character development and emotional payoff. DeepSeek’s focus on Elliot’s internal journey and the poetic reflection on fate and adventure gives it the edge, making it the winner.

3.Misheard Lyrics

Prompt:

Think of some of the song lyrics you have misheard throughout the years. Pick your favorite, and use these misheard lyrics as the title of a new creative writing piece. Write a story, scene, or poem based on this title.

ChatGPT Reply:

Deepseek Reply:

Winner: DeepSeek

While ChatGPT’s response, “Hold Me Closer, Tony Danza,” is heartfelt and captures a touching moment of connection to a lost loved one, DeepSeek’s version offers a richer narrative with deeper emotional layers and a more developed story arc. DeepSeek’s piece explores themes of serendipity, personal connection, and the beauty of misheard lyrics as a metaphor for making life your own. The interaction between the protagonist and Claire feels organic and meaningful, and the story’s resolution ties the misheard lyrics to a broader message about love and individuality.

ChatGPT’s response is sweet and nostalgic, with a strong emotional core, but it feels more contained and less expansive in its storytelling. DeepSeek’s ability to weave the misheard lyrics into a larger, more immersive narrative gives it the edge, making it the winner.

4.I’m Glad You Called

Prompt:

The person whom you or your character has been trying to talk to for ages finally answers the phone. Who is this person? Why were you or your character trying to track them down for so long? How does the phone conversation progress?

ChatGPT Reply:

Deepseek Reply:

Winner: DeepSeek

While ChatGPT’s response, “The Call That Took Too Long,” is emotionally charged and effectively captures the tension of a long-awaited conversation, DeepSeek’s “The Call” offers a more layered and intriguing narrative. DeepSeek’s story combines personal stakes with a larger, mysterious plot, weaving together themes of scientific discovery, danger, and existential curiosity. The conversation with Dr. Hart feels urgent and compelling, and the cliffhanger ending leaves the reader eager to know more.

ChatGPT’s response is poignant and relatable, focusing on family drama and unresolved grief, but it lacks the same level of complexity and originality. DeepSeek’s ability to blend emotional depth with a thrilling, sci-fi-inspired premise gives it the edge, making it the winner.

5.What’s Cooking?

Prompt:

As your character watches the hibachi chef prepare their meal, something seems off. What is it?

ChatGPT Reply:

Deepseek Reply:

Winner: DeepSeek

While ChatGPT’s response, “Fire and Steel,” is atmospheric and effectively builds tension with its eerie descriptions and unsettling tone, DeepSeek’s “The Chef’s Secret” offers a more layered and engaging narrative. DeepSeek’s story combines subtle hints of something being off with a tangible mystery (the metallic device), creating a sense of intrigue and urgency. The protagonist’s discovery of the device and the subsequent text message add depth and a clear direction to the plot, making it more compelling and open-ended.

ChatGPT’s response is strong in its brevity and ability to evoke unease, but it feels more like a snapshot than a complete story. DeepSeek’s ability to weave a mystery with tangible stakes and a clear hook gives it the edge, making it the winner.

6.Tornado Season

Prompt:

A tornado is forming and your character is in the absolute worst place they can be at the moment. Where are they? How do they handle the situation?

ChatGPT Reply:

Deepseek Reply:

Winner: DeepSeek

While ChatGPT’s response, “Trapped in the sky,” is tense and vividly describes the terror of being caught in a tornado, DeepSeek’s “Eye of the Storm” offers a more dynamic and layered narrative. DeepSeek’s story places the protagonist in a uniquely precarious situation—a suspension bridge—which adds an extra layer of danger and suspense. The detailed descriptions of the bridge’s instability and the protagonist’s resourcefulness in crawling to safety make the scene more immersive and gripping. Additionally, the ending, which hints at a deeper meaning or test, adds a philosophical dimension that elevates the story

ChatGPT’s response is strong in its simplicity and raw tension, but it lacks the same level of complexity and originality. DeepSeek’s ability to create a vivid, high-stakes scenario with a memorable resolution gives it the edge, making it the winner.

7.School Daze

Prompt:

Your character's child comes home with a detention slip to sign, but your character isn't angry. What's the reason that they aren't angry with their child for getting into trouble at school?

ChatGPT Reply:

Deepseek Reply:

Winner: DeepSeek

While ChatGPT’s response, “A detention worth taking,” is heartwarming and effectively conveys the pride a parent feels when their child stands up for others, DeepSeek’s “The Detention Slip” offers a more unique and thought-provoking scenario. DeepSeek’s story tackles a moral dilemma—animal dissection—that adds depth and complexity to the situation. The protagonist’s pride in their daughter’s ethical stance and the emphasis on courage and conviction make the narrative more impactful and memorable.

ChatGPT’s response is touching and relatable, but it follows a more predictable path. DeepSeek’s ability to address a less common but equally important issue gives it the edge, making it the winner.

8.Museum Artifacts

Prompt:

Take a look around a museum or recall your favorite pieces in a museum. Imagine what the past lives of these artifacts look like. Alternatively, you may imagine what the everyday objects in our lives might look like in a museum and what stories future generations will tell about them.

ChatGPT Reply:

Deepseek Reply:

Winner: DeepSeek

While ChatGPT’s response, “The artifacts of us,” is thought-provoking and offers a creative glimpse into how future generations might view our everyday objects, DeepSeek’s “Whispers of the Past” provides a richer, more immersive narrative. DeepSeek’s story delves into the imagined histories of museum artifacts, bringing them to life with vivid details and emotional depth. The focus on the Viking sword and Roman mosaic creates a sense of connection to the past, making the narrative both engaging and poignant.

ChatGPT’s response is clever and reflective, but it lacks the same level of storytelling and emotional resonance. DeepSeek’s ability to weave compelling tales around historical artifacts gives it the edge, making it the winner.

9.Thrift Store Finds

Prompt:

Take a trip to the thrift store or think about your latest trip. Pick one item you find interesting and imagine who its past owner(s) was. How did they use the item? Why did they end up donating it to the thrift store?

ChatGPT Reply:

Deepseek Reply:

Winner: DeepSeek

While ChatGPT’s response, “The Forgotten Typewriter,” is nostalgic and effectively captures the sentimental value of an object, DeepSeek’s “The Velvet Jacket” offers a more vivid and emotionally resonant narrative. DeepSeek’s story brings the jacket to life with rich details about its past owner, Eleanor, and her journey as a jazz singer. The connection between the jacket and Eleanor’s personal and professional life adds depth and poignancy to the story

ChatGPT’s response is touching and well-crafted, but it feels more straightforward and less layered. DeepSeek’s ability to create a compelling backstory with emotional weight gives it the edge, making it the winner.

10.What In The World?

Prompt:

Your character's day has been every sort of strange that you can imagine. Write about this day from their perspective—in the voice of a children's book.

ChatGPT Reply:

Deepseek Reply:

Winner: ChatGPT

While DeepSeek’s “The Day Everything Went Wonky” is imaginative and well-structured, ChatGPT’s “The Very, Very Strange Day of Oliver J. Wren” stands out for its playful, whimsical tone and its ability to capture the essence of a children’s book perfectly. ChatGPT’s story is filled with delightful absurdities—flying toasters, marshmallow clouds, and a talking apple tree teacher—that feel like they’ve leaped straight out of a child’s wildest dreams. The interactions between Sophie and her floating cat, Mr. Whiskers, add a charming and personal touch, making the story feel both magical and relatable.

DeepSeek’s narrative is creative and cohesive, but ChatGPT’s response leans more into the childlike wonder and randomness that makes children’s stories so enchanting. The simplicity and joy in ChatGPT’s tale, combined with its vivid imagery and lighthearted tone, give it the edge, making it the winner.

11.No One Can See Me

Prompt:

Re-write a scene or story from the point of view of someone or something that none of the characters knew was watching. It could be a ghost, animal, the furniture come to life, etc.

ChatGPT Reply:

Deepseek Reply:

DeepSeek vs. ChatGPT: Which One is More Creative?

I tested ChatGPT and DeepSeek with 11 creative writing prompts to see which AI writes better stories, poems, and ideas. The results? DeepSeek won 7 times, while ChatGPT won 4.

Who Did Better?

DeepSeek excelled in:

• Emotional, deep storytelling (e.g., vampires, thrift store finds)
• Unique, creative ideas (e.g., misheard lyrics, museum artifacts)
• Strong character-driven narratives

ChatGPT stood out in:

• Fun and playful writing (e.g., children’s stories)
• Suspenseful and eerie scenes (e.g., hibachi chef mystery)
• Concise, engaging storytelling

Strengths & Weaknesses

DeepSeek: Best for deep, emotional, and thought-provoking stories.
ChatGPT: Best for fun, structured, and engaging writing.

Final Verdict?

DeepSeek is better for deep, immersive stories.
ChatGPT is great for fun and engaging writing.

Want the best of both? Use ChatGPT for clarity and DeepSeek for emotion!

Tired of 9-5 Grind? This Program Could Be Turning Point For Your Financial FREEDOM.

This AI side hustle is specially curated for part-time hustlers and full-time entrepreneurs – you literally need PINTEREST + Canva + ChatGPT to make an extra $5K to $10K monthly with 4-6 hours of weekly work. It’s the most powerful system that’s working right now. This program comes with 3-months of 1:1 Support so there is almost 0.034% chances of failure! START YOUR JOURNEY NOW!